Competitive Analysis for Subscription Apps: Guide

The subscription app market is crowded, with millions of apps competing for attention on both the Apple App Store and Google Play. To succeed, you need a clear strategy based on competitive analysis. Here’s a quick summary of how to analyze your competitors and optimize your app:

Key Insights:

• Why It Matters: Competitive analysis helps you refine pricing, features, and marketing strategies to boost user acquisition and retention.

• Finding Competitors: Use app store rankings, categories, and ASO tools like AppTweak and App Radar to identify direct rivals, market leaders, and emerging threats.

• Pricing Strategies: Examine competitors’ subscription tiers, discounts, free trials, and regional pricing to identify gaps and opportunities.

• Feature Analysis: Compare core features, onboarding, user experience, and customization options to spot areas for improvement.

• Performance Metrics: Track app store reviews, rankings, churn rates, and revenue metrics like ARPU to understand what drives competitor success.

Quick Comparison Table:

By leveraging these insights, you can position your app to stand out, address user needs better than competitors, and achieve sustainable growth in a competitive market.

How to do app competitor analysis with App Radar?

How to Find Your Key Competitors in the Subscription App Market

To stay ahead in the subscription app market, you need a clear plan to identify not only the obvious competitors but also the lesser-known ones that could attract your audience.

Using App Store Rankings and Categories

App store rankings are a great starting point for spotting competitors. Both Google Play and Apple’s App Store group apps into categories, making it easier to find others in your space. Google Play features 34 categories in its top charts, while iOS organizes apps into 25 categories.

Start by exploring the top-performing apps in your category. Pay attention to their descriptions, screenshots, and overall presentation to identify apps directly competing with yours. Don’t stop there - use featured collections for deeper insights. For example, in November 2022, AppTweak highlighted how curated lists like "Try Something New" in the US App Store showcased niche apps, such as those focused on learning romance languages. These collections can help you uncover competitors you might miss by only browsing general categories.

Another valuable resource is the "Similar Apps" section on app product pages. These suggestions, generated by algorithms, show apps users often compare or download together. This can give you a window into user preferences without needing to invest in expensive research tools.

Use Keyword Research and ASO Tools

Keywords can reveal a lot about your competitors’ strategies. With 70% of App Store visitors using search to discover apps and 65% of downloads happening after a search, understanding the keywords your competitors target is crucial.

Tools like AppTweak, ASODesk, and App Radar can help you analyze competitor keyword strategies. These platforms let you see which search terms drive traffic to competing apps, helping you understand how they position themselves in the market.

Start by brainstorming keywords related to your app’s main features. Then, use ASO tools to expand your list. By analyzing competitors’ apps, you’ll uncover the keywords they’re using, how they rank for them, and any gaps you can take advantage of.

Pay attention to keyword clusters. A study found that 41% of top iOS apps and 47% of top Android apps include generic keywords in their titles, in addition to their brand names. This shows how much effort successful apps put into keyword optimization.

Here’s a quick comparison of popular ASO tools:

These tools not only help you refine your keyword strategy but also provide insights into how competitors are positioning themselves.

How to Classify Competitors by Market Presence

Once you’ve gathered data on competitors, it’s time to organize them based on their market presence and potential threat to your app.

• Market leaders: These are the dominant players with large user bases, strong funding, and well-established brands. They set the tone for the industry and shape user expectations.

• Direct rivals: These competitors are on a similar scale to your app. They target the same audience with comparable features and pricing, making them your most immediate concern.

• Emerging threats: These newer apps are rapidly gaining momentum. They might offer fresh features, lower prices, or unique approaches that could disrupt the market. Watch for apps climbing the rankings or getting media attention.

• Distant competitors: These apps address similar problems but cater to different audiences or use alternative business models. They’re worth monitoring but don’t require as much focus.

This classification helps you prioritize your research efforts. Focus most of your attention on direct rivals and emerging threats, while keeping an eye on market leaders for trends and distant competitors for potential opportunities to pivot.

Finally, set up a system to monitor competitors regularly. App store rankings change constantly, and new players enter the market all the time. Regular updates and reviews will help you stay informed and adapt as needed.

How to Analyze Competitor Pricing and Revenue Strategies

Once you've identified your competitors, the next step is to dive into their pricing and revenue strategies. This analysis can help you position your app more effectively in the market. For non-gaming apps, subscriptions account for an average of 82% of revenue, making this a key area to focus on when evaluating competitors' approaches. Here's how to break down subscription tiers, revenue models, and pricing structures for a clearer picture of the market landscape.

Review Subscription Tiers and Offers

Start by examining the subscription tiers your competitors offer. Providing multiple pricing levels can help cater to a variety of user segments and boost revenue potential. Pay close attention to the following:

• Structure and Features: Analyze how competitors present their pricing tiers, what features are included, and how they emphasize value at each level.

• Introductory Offers: Look at free trial periods (commonly 7, 14, or 30 days), discounted initial pricing, and other promotional deals designed to convert free users into paying customers.

• Annual vs. Monthly Plans: Many apps encourage annual subscriptions by offering significant discounts compared to monthly pricing. This approach not only improves cash flow but also helps reduce churn. Study how competitors implement these discounts.

• Lifetime Subscriptions: Some apps offer a one-time payment option for lifetime access to premium features. While this generates upfront revenue, it could impact long-term earnings. Evaluate whether competitors use this model and how it fits into their overall strategy.

• Regional Pricing: Competitors often adjust subscription costs based on local purchasing power and market conditions. If your app targets multiple regions, analyze how pricing varies across markets to align with user expectations.

Revenue Models and Mixed Approaches

Understanding competitors' broader revenue strategies can reveal untapped opportunities. Subscription apps typically rely on a few key models, each with its own pros and cons.

• Freemium Models: These allow users to access basic features for free, while premium features are locked behind a paywall. This strategy focuses on acquiring users first and converting them later. When analyzing freemium apps, note which features are free and which require payment. As Steve P. Young of App Masters advises:

  "Lock up as much as you can... Too many times I look at developers and I'm like, 'you just give away too much for free.'"

• Hard vs. Soft Paywalls: Hard paywalls block access to most content after a brief trial period, while soft paywalls allow limited free access before requiring payment. Research shows hard paywalls can achieve conversion rates up to 10 times higher than soft paywalls. Study how competitors use these strategies and their impact on user acquisition and retention.

• Hybrid Models: Some apps blend multiple revenue streams, such as subscriptions, one-time purchases, premium add-ons, or advertising. For example, The New York Times reported $2.3 billion in revenue in 2022, with $1.55 billion (67%) from subscriptions and $523 million (22.7%) from advertising. This approach diversifies income while offering users flexible options.

As you evaluate these models, pay close attention to the user experience. Look at how competitors introduce pricing during onboarding, how they present value propositions, and how they guide users from free to paid features.

Create a Pricing Strategy Comparison Table

To make sense of your findings, organize the data into a comparison table. This will highlight pricing patterns, gaps, and opportunities in the market. Your table should include:

• Pricing Details: List monthly, annual, and lifetime subscription costs, along with any discounts for long-term commitments. Include percentage discounts for annual plans to understand how aggressively competitors price these options.

• Key Features: Focus on standout features at each pricing tier to see how competitors structure their value offerings.

• Usage Restrictions: Note any limits on projects, storage, or transactions, as these can influence how users perceive value.

• Payment Options: Record the payment methods competitors accept, such as credit cards, PayPal, or Apple Pay. Also, note any user-friendly features like pause options or easy cancellation policies.

How to Compare Features and User Experience

Once you've wrapped up your pricing analysis, it’s time to dive into how competitors deliver value through their features and user experience. This step helps you spot gaps in the market and discover opportunities to stand out, aligning pricing, features, and user experience as the key components of your competitive strategy.

Compare Features One by One

Break down your competitors' features into categories, focusing on both their availability and how effectively they’re executed.

Here are some key areas to analyze:

• Core functionality: These are the essential features that form the backbone of any subscription app. For instance, productivity apps might focus on task management, collaboration tools, or automation, while entertainment apps might highlight their content libraries, streaming quality, or personalization options. Identify what each competitor’s core value proposition is built on.

• Onboarding and user activation: First impressions matter. Look at how competitors introduce new users to their platforms. Do they use tutorials, progressive feature rollouts, or quick-start guides? Some apps aim for instant gratification, while others provide a more detailed, step-by-step onboarding experience.

• Integration capabilities: Check which third-party services, APIs, or platforms competitors connect to. This is especially critical for B2B apps, where seamless integration can lock users in by increasing switching costs.

• Mobile vs. desktop experiences: Note whether competitors lean toward mobile-first designs or prioritize desktop functionality. Pay attention to how well features are synchronized across devices and whether the experience feels consistent.

• Customization and personalization: Investigate how much control users have over their experience. Are there options for interface tweaks or advanced personalization based on user behavior? These features can make a big difference in user satisfaction.

Once you’ve gathered this data, map out how these features fit into the user journey.

Map Out the User Journey

After assessing features, it’s essential to understand how they contribute to the overall user journey. This step provides insight into customer interactions, pain points, and opportunities for improvement.

Start by mapping the journey from signup to conversion and retention. Pay attention to the number of steps required to sign up, whether payment details are requested upfront, and how premium features are introduced. Note if users can explore the app for free or if they’re required to commit immediately.

Next, examine the path to subscription conversion. Identify when and how competitors prompt users to upgrade - whether through usage limits, feature restrictions, or timed notifications. Observe how these prompts are framed: do they highlight missing features, or do they emphasize added value?

Finally, explore retention and engagement tactics. Look for strategies like targeted email campaigns, in-app notifications, or feature updates designed to keep users engaged. Also, evaluate how competitors handle lapsed users or encourage subscription renewals.

Customer journey maps can reveal hidden friction points. As Alix Carman from Adjust explains:

"Customer journey maps highlight pain points within marketing campaigns that can often go unnoticed."

Document any areas where you encounter challenges, such as confusing navigation, missing features, or technical glitches that could hinder user success.

Create a Feature and UX Comparison Table

To organize your findings, create a comparison table highlighting core features, unique capabilities, user experience elements, and support options. Use qualitative ratings like "Basic" or "Advanced" to make differences between competitors more apparent. As Kate Moran and Taylor Dykes from Nielsen Norman Group explain:

"Comparison table: A table that uses columns for products (or services) and rows for the attributes. It allows for quick and easy comparison between each offering's features and characteristics."

Your table should focus on the most important differentiators rather than listing every single feature. Include:

• Core features that define each app’s primary value.

• Unique capabilities that make competitors stand out.

• User experience elements like onboarding quality, mobile responsiveness, and customer support.

Don’t forget to evaluate support and community features. Some competitors go the extra mile with live chat, detailed documentation, or active user communities. These can significantly impact user satisfaction and retention, even if they aren’t directly tied to the app’s main functionality.

As the Nielsen Norman Group points out:

"The biggest problem with most comparison tables isn't design, it's content."

Make sure your comparisons are consistent and focus on equivalent features across all competitors.

This structured approach to analyzing features and user experience will help you uncover market gaps and refine your competitive positioning. The insights you gain can directly shape your product roadmap and strategy.

How to Evaluate Market Position and Performance Metrics

Understanding market position goes beyond just comparing prices and features; performance metrics offer a deeper look into what drives a competitor's success - or exposes their weaknesses. By analyzing these metrics, you can gain valuable insights to refine your strategy and strengthen your position.

Analyze App Store Reviews and Rankings

App store reviews and rankings provide a treasure trove of information about how competitors are performing in the market. With 77% of users checking reviews before downloading an app, these reviews not only influence user acquisition but also reveal customer sentiment and areas for improvement.

Take a closer look at review trends over time. For instance, a surge in negative reviews might indicate issues with a recent update, while consistent positive feedback often points to a strong alignment with user needs. Pay attention to keyword rankings and category positions as well. If a competitor climbs the rankings for relevant search terms, it could signal successful optimization efforts. On the flip side, a drop might present an opportunity for you to step in and capture visibility.

User reviews also highlight recurring feature requests, which can help you identify unmet needs in the market. Don’t overlook negative feedback - research shows that people are 21% more likely to leave a review after a bad experience than a good one. These insights not only shed light on user pain points but also guide engagement and retention strategies.

Track Engagement and Retention Metrics

Engagement and retention metrics are crucial for understanding how well competitors are keeping their users - and how much revenue they’re generating. While some data can be estimated through third-party tools, even broad trends can offer valuable clues.

Subscription apps, for example, often focus on churn rates. Industry averages show that subscription businesses lose 4.1% of their customers each month, with 3.0% due to voluntary churn and 1.0% due to involuntary churn. Ideally, churn rates should stay between 5% and 7%; anything higher signals potential retention issues. By keeping an eye on user acquisition patterns and app store rankings, you can infer how well a competitor is retaining its audience.

Revenue metrics like Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) and Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) growth are also telling. These can often be estimated using app store revenue rankings or analytics platforms. Remember, ARPU accounts for all users, while Average Revenue Per Paying User (ARPPU) focuses exclusively on those who make purchases.

As Team Braze explains:

"Mobile application KPIs are the metrics that help marketers understand how users interact with their app and whether those experiences lead to long-term value. These indicators help show which strategies are working and where to improve."

Cohort analysis can also be a powerful tool. By examining how different groups of users behave over time, you can uncover patterns in subscriber retention and identify areas for improvement. Pairing this with ongoing competitor analysis helps you stay ahead in a crowded market.

Monitor Competitor Updates and Changes

Keeping tabs on competitor updates is just as important as analyzing metrics. Changes in features, pricing, or marketing strategies can signal shifts in their market approach and reveal opportunities for you.

Use tools to track updates and metadata changes. This includes monitoring both tactical moves - like new product launches or promotional offers - and strategic shifts that hint at long-term goals. For example, regional pricing experiments or subscription tier adjustments can indicate whether a competitor is struggling with pricing strategy, potentially opening the door for your app to gain traction.

When competitors roll out new features, pay close attention to user reactions. Reviews and engagement metrics can offer a quick snapshot of how well the update is being received. Positive feedback might highlight features worth prioritizing in your own roadmap, while negative responses can help you avoid similar missteps.

To make sense of all this data, consider creating a competitive dashboard. By consolidating insights from reviews, engagement metrics, and competitor updates, you’ll be better equipped to spot trends and act quickly. Regularly analyzing these performance metrics not only helps you learn from competitors' successes and failures but also positions your app for meaningful growth in the subscription market.

Conclusion: How to Use Your Competitive Analysis Results

Your detailed competitor research isn't just a report to file away - it’s a tool to drive growth. Here’s how to put those insights into action.

Turn pricing insights into a competitive edge. Did you know that 80% of buyers compare prices and offers before making a purchase? Your pricing strategy has to stand out while remaining competitive. Use your research to spot pricing gaps and create subscription packages or features that competitors haven’t tapped into. For instance, if competitors dominate with annual plans, consider offering flexible monthly trials. On the flip side, if the market is saturated with monthly options, a discounted annual plan could set you apart.

Keep a close eye on how pricing changes impact revenue, customer retention, and feedback. Also, monitor your competitors’ discount strategies, promotional codes, and special offers to develop approaches that resonate with your audience.

Let market intelligence shape your feature development. Your analysis doesn’t just show what features competitors offer - it also reveals how users feel about them. Dive into competitor reviews to see what users love and where they’re frustrated. If a competitor gets glowing feedback on a certain feature, think about how you can adapt it with your own spin.

But don’t get caught in a feature race. As Saeed Khan, a product management expert with 20 years of experience, wisely said:

"Competitive analysis is not about feature wars. It's about differentiation, value delivered and competitive positioning. You can't win a feature war, because for any feature you have that they don't, they have something you don't have. It's also a poor way to show value."

Instead, focus on solving problems competitors ignore. Addressing user complaints that others overlook can position your app as the go-to choice without falling into the trap of endless feature-matching.

Position your app to stand out. Your research should uncover ways to make your app truly distinct. Highlight what sets your subscription apart - whether it’s an intuitive user experience, standout features, stellar customer service, or a fresh business model.

Find competitor weaknesses and turn them into your strengths. If their onboarding process is clunky, simplify yours. If they rely too heavily on paywalls, offer meaningful free trials or a balanced freemium model. The aim is to align your strategy with what your audience values while addressing gaps others leave behind.

Stay vigilant by tracking competitor launches and user reactions. The market is always evolving, and being adaptable keeps you ahead of the curve.

The best subscription apps don’t just analyze competitors - they use those insights to create something better. Your research is your roadmap. The next step is execution. Combine these insights with ongoing performance tracking to ensure you’re not just keeping up but leading the way.

FAQs

How can I use app store tools to spot potential threats in the subscription app market?

To keep an eye on potential threats in the subscription app market, use app store tools to track critical signals. Make it a habit to review user feedback and ratings frequently - this can help you identify recurring complaints or possible security issues. Watch for sudden shifts in app rankings or download patterns, as these could hint at emerging competitors or suspicious activities. It's also important to stay updated on policy changes and new app releases that might influence your standing in the market. App store analytics and built-in security tools are valuable resources to help you stay ahead and manage risks effectively.

What are the best strategies for creating subscription tiers that attract and retain users?

To design subscription tiers that effectively drive user acquisition and retention, focus on simplicity and clear value. Your tiers should be easy to understand, with well-defined differences in features and pricing. This helps users quickly grasp the advantages of upgrading. Make sure to offer options that cater to a range of budgets and needs, ensuring every tier feels worthwhile.

Adding free trials or limited-time introductory deals can entice users to test out premium features. Pair this with flexible billing options, like monthly or annual plans, to suit different preferences. It's also important to create a pricing structure that grows with your users, ensuring they can continue using your app without feeling constrained. By delivering real benefits and prioritizing user satisfaction at every level, you can build loyalty and keep churn to a minimum.

How can I use user feedback and app store reviews to improve my app's competitive edge?

To give your app a stronger edge in the market, make it a priority to gather and analyze user feedback and app store reviews. Encourage your users to leave detailed reviews - these often highlight common frustrations, feature requests, and areas needing improvement. Look for recurring patterns in the feedback and address them through updates to boost user satisfaction and improve your app's ratings.

Stay on top of feedback trends to spot changes in user expectations. This insight lets you tweak your app’s features or adjust its positioning to stay relevant. By actively listening to your audience and responding to their needs, you can make your app more appealing and keep a solid footing in the competitive world of subscription-based apps.

Related posts

• 5 Steps for Mobile App Competitor Analysis

• How To Fix Low-Performing Keywords In App Store

• Freemium 101: Features That Drive Conversions